鱿鱼视频app

hand and heart

The recent post office troubles have impacted our regular fundraising efforts. Please consider supporting the Register and Catholic journalism by using one of the methods below:

  • Donate online
  • Donate by e-transfer to accounting@catholicregister.org
  • Donate by telephone: 416-934-3410 ext. 406 or toll-free 1-855-441-4077 ext. 406
Sr. Nuala Kenny Michael Swan

Dealing with abuse a work in progress

By 
  • March 22, 2023

Publishing the names of credibly accused child sex abusers, as Canada鱿鱼视频app Jesuit Fathers did March 12, is one small step toward creating a better Church, but it鱿鱼视频app not enough for abuse survivor John Swales.

For Swales, who was sexually exploited by Fr. Barry Glendinning between 1969 and 1974 in London, Ont., transparency about past sexual abuse is a good first step. But transparency must be accompanied by accountability, Swales told The Catholic Register

鈥淭he question that needs to be answered is, 鈥榃hy? Why are we here? What are we going to do about it?鈥 Accountability really reigns high,鈥 he said. 鈥淚f the question is, 鈥榃ould that build a better Church?鈥 Absolutely.鈥

Swales won鈥檛 get an argument from Canada鱿鱼视频app most recognized expert on clerical sexual abuse, Sr. Nuala Kenny.

鈥淭ransparency and accountability are key in atonement and developing a culture of safeguarding,鈥 she said in an e-mail. 鈥淲e are slowly learning how to implement them.鈥

Since serving on the Winter Commission that investigated the Mount Cashel child sexual abuse scandal in Newfoundland in 1989, Kenny has watched Church leadership slowly walk away from its impulse  to secrecy.

鈥淭here is no question that secrecy, silence, denial and cover-up are at the heart of all sexual abuse. They take a particular turn when the offender is a cleric, an Alter Christus, because sexual abuse is an abuse of power, position, trust and conscience,鈥 Kenny said.

"Transparency and accountability are key in atonement and developing a culture of safeguarding ... We are slowly learning how to implement them. "

- Sr. Nuala Kenny

It鱿鱼视频app in that context that Kenny praises the Canadian Jesuits鈥 decision to publish the names of credibly accused abusers gleaned from 70 years of the order鱿鱼视频app records.

鈥淐anada鱿鱼视频app Jesuits have acted with justice and prudence by publicly naming abusers in the order,鈥 she said.

That such facts will be public and should be public is increasingly accepted among religious orders. For the Benedictines of Westminster Abbey in Mission, B.C., an hour鱿鱼视频app drive east of Vancouver, conducting an audit and publishing names aren鈥檛 really an issue, said Abbot Alban Riley.

鈥淥ur small size means we don鈥檛 need an audit,鈥 the Abbot said in an e-mail to The Catholic Register. 鈥淭he only member accused, Fr. Placidus Sander, has been published by the Vancouver Archdiocese as part of their disclosure, because we run the Archdiocesan seminary.鈥

For the Basilian Fathers, an international order headquartered in Toronto, it鱿鱼视频app a little more complicated. For the last 17 years the Basilians have entrusted monitoring their sexual abuse policies and management of cases to an outside consulting company that specializes in sexual abuse policies in all sorts of organizations, religious and secular. The Basilians鈥 contract with Praesidium Inc., based in Arlington, Tex., effectively subjects the order to a permanent audit.

鈥淭he decision to release a list of those credibly accused is very complicated,鈥 Basilian superior general Fr. Kevin Storey said in an e-mail.

While that complicated question remains open, Storey points to significant safeguarding and accountability now baked into Basilian life. 鈥淪ince 1992, all candidates for the Basilian Fathers must pass psychological screening by independent assessors and have annual reviews and growth plans,鈥 Storey said. 

Without question and without hesitation, the Basilians call the police and co-operate in all legal investigations whenever one of their own is accused, said Storey. 

They also call in a review board of lay professionals to review incidents, even if they don鈥檛 rise to the level of a police investigation.

For the Canadian Oblates of Lacombe Province, who operated 48 of Canada鱿鱼视频app infamous residential schools, naming names is only one part of providing greater transparency 鈥 though it鱿鱼视频app a step they haven鈥檛 taken yet.

鈥淥ver the last year, we have heard calls for additional transparency and are actively reviewing how other religious entities 鈥攊ncluding the Jesuits 鈥 have approached additional disclosures,鈥 provincial superior Fr. Ken Thorson told The Catholic Register in an e-mail. 鈥淲ith an aim to identifying any possible improvements that balance the need for transparency and respect for victims鈥 right to privacy.鈥

That said, the Oblates of Mary Immaculate 鈥渟upport any victim or survivor who chooses to do so (publicly name their abuser) and expect secular authorities to report any charges and convictions,鈥 Thorson said.

While there are many legal questions around going public with the names of abusers, lawyer Mary Margaret MacKinnon doesn鈥檛 believe that victim privacy or possible re-traumatizing of victims is the big issue.

鈥淭here may be the occasional victim who feels traumatized by seeing a photo of somebody, but I鈥檝e worked with lots of victims groups as well and they would say the value of having some information about these people so we can move forward with our healing far outweighs the few people who can just not look at that picture again. I don鈥檛 buy that,鈥 MacKinnon told The Catholic Register.

MacKinnon, of Guild Yule LLP, headed up the Archdiocese of Vancouver鱿鱼视频app 2019 audit of nearly 80 years of abuse files, and has consulted with religious orders across Canada on similar audits. The big issue when it comes to publishing names is a clear definition of 鈥渃redibly accused.鈥

"Publishing the names of offenders can become an opportunity for the Catholic Church to confront its past in order to better its future."

- Hans Zollner

鈥淚t鱿鱼视频app not 51 per cent. It鱿鱼视频app going to be something where you have some solid basis for believing those allegations are true,鈥 MacKinnon said.

How we define 鈥渃redibly accused鈥 matters even more if the people named are still alive. The threat of libel action is not insubstantial, particularly in Canada where there is no First Amendment-free speech right to hide behind. There鱿鱼视频app also the issue of provinces, such as British Columbia, which have Protection of Individual Privacy Acts (PIPA) that enshrine privacy rights in the law. Even in provinces that don鈥檛 have PIPA legislation, a reasonable right to privacy is part of common law and will be given deference in courts. 

Gregorian University psychology professor and Pope Francis鈥 point man on sexual abuse, Jesuit Fr. Hans Zollner, is in favour of publishing names when possible.

鈥淧ublishing the names of offenders can become an opportunity for the Catholic Church to confront its past in order to better its future,鈥 Zollner told The Catholic Register in an e-mail. 鈥淭he act of recognizing not only those who have betrayed their ministry, but also how abuse was allowed to continue without accountability can help dioceses and religious communities enact the necessary means to prevent it from happening again and to fully endorse much-needed protocols and guidelines to protect minors and vulnerable adults.鈥

The legal landscape around the world doesn鈥檛 always make this possible. 鈥淣orth Americans are quite surprised when they learn that, according to data protection law, the publication of full names even of convicted criminals is not allowed in the European Union, with some exceptions, let alone the names of persons who are alleged or credibly accused offenders,鈥 Zollner said.

The Church also faces significant cultural barriers in parts of the world where it is a large presence and growing 鈥 Africa and Latin America.

鈥淪exuality and especially sexual misconduct very often isn鈥檛 spoken about in families or society, either due to shame or because it is considered a taboo subject,鈥 Zollner said. He fears a future in which the media and courts will force transparency on reluctant Church institutions.

鈥淚t is imperative that individual bishops鈥 conferences and dioceses present in those regions find an effective way to respond to victims and to be transparent and accountable, in full accordance with the laws of states or countries, and help to modify cultural barriers around such society/family/Church secrets,鈥 he said.

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.

DONATE